Loggerhead Cay #224

Review Date: 06/20/2022

This was an excellent condo! Very spacious and clean. Close walk to beach - Kasey P., ,

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/10/2022

My wife and have made this a yearly trip for the past few years renting the same property on the same week. Our experience has been so positive we see no reason to go elsewhere and have already booked next year. Year to year improvements have been made to the property, ALL of the staff at Select Vacations has been great to deal with over the years. The location itself is fabulous. If you are looking for a no nonsense quiet get a way with an ocean view this is the place, yet it is still close to the many attractions in the area. I highly recommend this company and it’s property we keep booking ahead so we don’t lose out. As an aside during the height of the recent pandemic we were unable to make it to our booked time on very short notice. Instead of just taking our money select vacations allowed us to defer to the following year at the same rate. That sold us for good , wish I could say the same for the airline that hosed us. - Anonymous, Taunton, MA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 03/01/2022

We had a wonderful time in Sanibel and at our condo. The location was great right on the beach, near bike trails and convenient to many activities. - Rose R., Plainwell, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 02/21/2022

Condo was nice. Kitchen was great. Lots of chairs and an umbrella to use. The condo complex was not kid friendly. Adult swim from 8-9 and 4-5. The grills are far from the condo and not working great. - Anonymous, FARIBAULT, MN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others No

Review Date: 04/11/2022

This was our second year in a row staying at Loggerhead Cay 224, just a great experience! The unit was clean and very accommodating. Location is perfect and the views are amazing. The entire team at Select Vacation Properties goes above and beyond for a memorable and enjoyable experience. - Michael M., Grand Rapids, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 01/25/2022

Clean, well stocked, fabulous views, all around super for us. - Steve R., Mason, OH

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 06/15/2020

We had a wonderful stay in Unit 224. The condo is decorated in a tasteful, relaxing style, and the kitchen had everything we needed. The management company was a dream to work with from start to finish and made me feel very cared for! The view is wonderful, maybe better than the pictures show. We have stayed at Loggerhead Cay four times and enjoy the property's location and landscaping--it's beautiful. We will try to stay in this unit for our next trip to Sanibel. - Laura Lee S., Knoxville, TN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 12/28/2020

Was so perfect I did not want to leave - Anonymous, las vegas, United States

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 02/19/2021

We had an issue with our original unit. The management company immediately placed us in a different unit. They were very professional and excellent to work with. Nice property in a great location. Sanibel island is worth a visit! - Anonymous, Boone, IA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 02/16/2021

Our condo was clean and updated and well stocked . The location was perfect . Loved the ocean view - Anonymous, ,

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/03/2021

My husband and I spent April 10th throught April 17 on Sanibel Island. We have been a few times. This was first time renting a condo. We really enjoyed the location. The condo was clean and fully stocked. My only suggestion would be to possibly update the couch. It was uncomfortable to sit on let alone lay on but that would be my only complaint. Great locaton. - Susan E., Toms River, NJ

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/05/2021

Our vacation rental experience was seamless. Loved the keyless entry so our vacation could start immediately as we crossed over the bridge to Sanibel. Location was perfect, with gorgeous view of ocean and pool. Our condo was super clean. Amenities were generous. Plenty of linens, samples selection (laundry detergent, dish detergent, dish soap, paper towels, toilet paper, garbage bags, hand sanitizer, countertop cleaner). It prevents you from having to go to the grocery store for a couple of days. There were beach toys, chairs, umbrellas also available. I have never rented where beach towels were available. Wow! More room in my suitcase for souvenirs. I plan to return and have already shared the info with my neighbor who is planning a trip to Sanibel. The resort is well maintained and just lovely overall. Very quiet too, which is a rarity. I'm a light sleeper and usually am wakened by the slightest noise. This trip and these accommodations was exceptional. I highly recommend. - Anonymous, bedford, NH

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/24/2021

We really enjoyed our stay here - beautiful beach and nice pool. The unit itself is large, and we enjoyed it. Has most everything you need. It could use a bit of updating - new carpet or tile floor, new towels (a bit discolored), new pillows - theirs were a hodgepodge, most were flat and smelled old. I know that all sounds like it is a bad place - it isn't. It was good, just needs a facelift in some areas. - Anonymous, Westerville, OH

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 07/26/2021

Condo and location were great. - Jerry A., Columbus, OH

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 02/27/2017

Sanibel Island contains great bike riding trails, plenty of great restaurants, snd lots of shopping opportunities. We attended Sanibel Community Church while there and it was very nice. - Anonymous, Butler, Ky

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/09/2017

Absolutely love unit 224. Will be back 2018, hoping for a upgraded master bedroom bed �� - Joel W., Howell, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 06/30/2017

VERY GOOD. - Gary W., Oxford, OX26 3WW

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/20/2017

We travel every year mid-May to celebrate a birthday. We have been all over Florida, but Sanibel Island is unique and wonderful so we have returned on several occasions. - Anonymous, Madison, WI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 07/18/2017

It was wonderful. Our condo was perfect. Blow dryer did smoke so I left in on the table. - Bill M., Duluth, GA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/15/2018

We love Loggerhead Cay and unit 224... - Joel W., Howell, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 10/26/2018

My family and I stayed at Loggerhead Cay #224 in April of 2018. The property was well maintained and easily accessed. We would have liked to have a closer view of the ocean, but the unit made up for this detail in its decor and comfort. The third floor location was quiet and allowed us to view the well-kept grounds and swimming pool. Everything we required to enjoy our stay was provided. The management company was terrific. I really can't think of any negatives and I wouldn't hesitate to rent #224 again. - Anonymous, Eden Prairie, MN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 07/13/2018

Condo was great! Nice path to beach with easy walkways. Minutes from everything. - Julie P., LANCASTER, KY

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 12/31/2018

We have been planning this trip to celebrate our 40 yrs of marriage & turning 60 yrs old since last February 2018. We enjoyed this stay tremendously and appreciate the owner, Patience Rodriguez,for taking such good care of the condo. It was clean and well equipped!
The only thing I would suggest would be to update the comforters on the beds and replace the front screen door to make it more updated. These are clearly just cosmetic changes but it would make a visual difference. - Anonymous, Blue Springs, MO

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 11/29/2018

we really enjoyed our vacation at Loggerhead Cay. Everything was better than we could imagine, and the facility is spotless and amazing. Will definitely be returning if possible. - Anonymous, sellersburg, IN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 10/15/2018

We enjoyed staying at Loggerhead Cay. This was are first vacation at Sanibel Island, we we vacationing for our son's wedding. The property was incredible, great views of pool and ocean, great layout for two families, very clean and had everything that we needed. I would definitely return and highly recommend to others. - Deborah F., Kenna, WV

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 01/26/2019

I have absolutely no complaints about this unit. The condo was wonderfully equipped and very clean. The view and proximity to beach and pool was perfect for young kids and grandparents. - Katelyn T., Egg Harbor Township, NJ

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 02/20/2019

Staying at Loggerhead Cay and having the beach at our doorstep was amazing. - Chris C., British Columbia, Canada

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 01/22/2020

This is a great condo, clean, well equipped and beautiful view. Keep in mind that it is on the fourth floor which elevates the view but makes running back and forth to the beach and common areas more of a challenge. There is an elevator as well as stairs. - Anonymous, Peoria, IL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 01/13/2020

We rented this unit for a week during Christmas. The unit was absolutely perfect. It was clean, well stocked, and everything was in great condition. The beds, in both rooms, were very comfortable. The condo was within minutes walking distance to the beach. This was our first trip to Sanibel and we enjoyed the island. We would love to come back and rent this unit again. - Jeannie R., Wayne, Pennsylvania

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 04/21/2014

We take our boys to sanibel every spring break since 1999. We love coming to Loggerhead Cay and spending quality time. Loved the new carpet and granite looks beautiful. Thanks for sharing your unit ;)) - Joel W., Howell, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 08/13/2013

Great place to vacation plenty to do and see. Lots of great restaurant . - Anonymous, West Palm Beach, FL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 11/30/2013

Our week on Sanibel was the best! The condo was very clean and we loved everything about it. Well stocked with towels and chairs for the beach. The lanai had a great view of the pool and gulf and it was wonderful just to sit out on it every morning with our coffee. Weather was also great, so couldn't ask for more. - Bob K., Cottage Grove, Wi

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 03/15/2014

This condo is well equipped, nicely decorated with a great view of the shore from the lanai - Charles H., Indianapolis, IN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 01/01/2014

We stayed at Loggerhead Cay for the 7th or 8th time over the winter break and had a wonderful time. It was our first time in this particular unit and we were very pleased. Loggerhead Cay is a great location. Right on the beach, nice size pool and tennis courts. The buildings are well maintained. We have stayed in a number of condos on the property and always had an excellent experience. The staff at Select Vacations are wonderful. This year we worked with Linda. We originally booked a different rental at a facility that had three bedrooms, which we thought was a good idea for our family of 5 and growing teens. Our kids had a mutiny and insisted we stay at Loggerhead Cay in a two bedroom with all the familiar amenities that we have come to love. Linda was great at switching the renatl, without any hassles. The particular unit we stayed in even had sand toys and tennis racquets for guests to borrow. Overall, a fabulous stay and we would happily work with Select Vacations again, as we have done for almost 10 years. - Helayna S., Toronto, Canada

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 12/14/2013

The unit was exactly as it was portrayed; the beds were excellent, the location was fabulous, the grounds were very well maintained. Having rented VRBO units all over the country I might suggest that some additional items be supplied for the kitchen and bathrooms that have been included in many past rentals i.e. shampoo, herbs and spices, plastic wrap or baggies - just little things that are very wasteful to buy for a week but make a nice, inexpensive difference to guests. - Larry L., Bozeman, MT

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 04/19/2014

We had a great week at the Loggerhead Cay condo. The unit was very functional, attractive, and clean. Enjoyed the view of the Gulf and the beach. Found plenty of things to do in the area. - Anonymous, Chippewa Falls, WI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 03/09/2015

This condo is an award winning combination of view (Gulf of Mexico), very well and furnished condo and great location (Sanibel Island). Who could ask for more!
- Charles H., Indianapolis, IN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 07/27/2014

Our experience started with the email conversation with the owner. He was prompt in his replies and quickly scheduled our time there. The property company was also quick in getting the needed forms to us to secure the rental. This property was just as lovely as the pictures and the view was even better. The property was very clean and well appointed with everything that you need for an extended visit. You didn't even need to bring beach items such as chairs or umbrellas, that meant getting right out on the beach without delay. We really only had 2 small issues with the property. The door was very hard to close from the outside as it was very tight due to the humidity. This was mentioned to the property company at the time of check out. It probably just needed shaved just bit and would be just right. Also there were so many remotes it was hard to figure out which one to use. Would recommend, if possible, a single universal remote. Otherwise, we had no complaints and felt right at home immediately upon arrival. Our only regret was that we had to leave. You are located close to many of the shops, restaurants and other amenities. If you choose this property, you will NOT be disappointed. I would recommend this property to anyone traveling to Sanibel and look forward to our next trip here so that we can stay here too!! - Diane C., Scott, WV

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 04/29/2015

We love Logger Head Cay - Joel W., Howell, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 08/05/2014

This week was our final week with our kids before they head off to college. We had a great time at the beach and playing games in the condo. This condo was the most stocked one we've ever rented before. The kitchen was awesome and the extra blankets came in handy when tired and chilled from a long day at the beach. I can't say enough how appreciative we were to have the 5 beach chairs, towels and umbrella to use for the week. We didn't have to haul all of that down with us and it was wonderful. Thanks for a great week! - Linda M., ,

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 09/11/2014

Our condo was lovely! The kitchen was supplied with everything that you could ever need. Peaceful and comfortable ! The only thing that could be better,the beach towels were hideous. - Anonymous, Niagara Falls, NY

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 07/17/2015

Stayed June 24th for 1 week. Apartment is in a lovely, well maintained site. It was very clean and comfortable and had everything we needed to meet all our needs including beach furniture. It overlooks the pool and has a good view of the ocean. Sanibel is beautiful. No more needs to be said. I only spoke to the team from Select Vacations on arrival and departure however I feel that they where engaging and approachable and would sort out any problems you might have very quickly... We had none!! Overall I would recommend and I would stay again.... - Alan G., maghaberry, Moira

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 02/23/2015

very good experance - Anonymous, Indianapolis, IN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 05/23/2015

Loggerhead Cay was very nice. Great location makes it easy to get to beach and get off/on the island. Very quiet and relaxing. - Anonymous, Madison, WI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 06/12/2015

This was our first time staying on this part of the Sanibel Island. We loved the convienence and location. In 7 days we only left the island only twice which really added to the relaxation and comfort. Beautifully landscaped property, clean and well maintained. - Anonymous, Burlington, KY

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 04/13/2016

The weather was perfect, the location was very good, the view was most enjoyable, and the unit was in excellent condition. Working with Select Vacation Rentals was easy and efficient. I'm ready to return next year! - Anonymous, Aurora, OH

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 04/04/2016

Awesome time with the Fam!!! - Joel W., Howell, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 12/13/2016

Great place to stay! - Anonymous, Healy, AK

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 04/14/2016

We had a wonderful time at this rental. Booking the rental and picking up keys through Select vacation Properties was very easy and efficient. The property was very clean, had a great location, and offered plenty of amenities. We would definitely stay her again! - Garrette B., Troy, MI

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 08/02/2016

Wonderful experience, would rent again. - Jennifer G., Senoia, GA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 07/02/2016

Beautiful condo with a view of the ocean. It was very spacious and fit my family of 5 great. If we have another baseball tourney in Ft. Myers again, I plan on renting this unit again. - Anonymous, Marietta, GA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 01/18/2017

Condo was very nice, very well equipped , great ocean view. I was very satisfied with my stay. - Anonymous, ,

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Review Date: 10/24/2016

Loggerhead Cay 224 is an exceptional condo! It's very clean, nicely decorated, has extra linens and towels and all the kitchen supplies anyone would need. We will stay here again! - Sally M., Nashville, TN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes