Loggerhead Cay #261

My wife and I and our teenage daughter came from Utah for Spring Break. We loved the location, and we also really liked the property. However, the master bed was broken and un-sleepable. My wife and I had many sleepless nights and I ended up sleeping on the couch to get some sleep. We would totally come back to this exact condo, ONLY if we are assured they have purchased a new master bed. For sure ask about that first. We informed the property managers and they were very kind and responsive and said they would inform the owners. Of course there was nothing they could do for our stay. The ground floor location was great, and the access to the beach is wonderful. - David B., Salt Lake City, UT

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

I have been booking the same unit at Loggerhead Cay through Select Vacation Properties since I first started spending my winters on Sanibel Island in December of 2013, and have already made a booking from December 10, 2022 to March 4, 2023.

The property description is accurate, and the owners who purchased the unit in the summer of 2021 have already done a lot to spruce up the place. In fact, I suspected as soon as I arrived that there had been a change in ownership, which was confirmed when I subsequently inquired.

The grounds are well maintained and there are lots flower beds and lovely shrubs and trees. The condominium rules are fairly strict and quite well enforced, which results in a safe and generally fairly quiet setting.

The folks at Select Vacation Properties provided outstanding customer service as always, and maintenance/purchase requests were addressed promptly in a highly satisfactory manner.

My sister and brother-in-law have visited me at Loggerhead Cay Unit 261 in the past and thoroughly enjoyed their stay, and are looking forward to doing so again next winter. My boyfriend always flies down with me and helps me to get moved in and settled, visited for a week in February this year, and joined me for a six-day stay at the end of my vacation and on the return flight to Pearson International Airport.

Because of the Omicron outbreak, I remained fairly socially isolated, and didn't walk to the library to pick up or exchange books or eat out at all this winter. As usual, though, I thoroughly enjoyed a lengthy (2 1/2 hour) beach walk virtually every afternoon.





- Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Overall the property was very nice. Short walk to the beach and convenient to restaurants and shops. Only a couple of issues were noted.....The second bathroom had not been cleaned from the previous occupants. The ice dispenser does not work so you have to open the door to get ice. Some of the furnishings need updating. The sliding doors leading to the porch are a bit hard to operate. This was a pet-friendly unit which was great. Even with these minor issues we were quite happy with the unit. - Mary P., Clinton, MS

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

The property and unit were very clean and well maintained. This is exactly as pictured with a beautiful kitchen well stocked with all the necessary utensils and appliances to cook. Unit is located a short walk to the pool and beach in a very safe and quiet neighborhood. Very dog friendly community and my dog loved walks on the beach. The screened in lanai faces the well maintained courtyard. There were plenty of linens, including towels. This was a wonderful experience including online check-in. I never had the opportunity to meet the property manager, Linda, but every time we spoke on the phone she was very polite and helpful, including phoning the day after Tropical Storm Elsa to check on us. - Toni C., Miami, FL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This was our first year staying at Loggerhead Cay and we really enjoyed it! The grounds were very well kept and the tennis court was a huge hit! The condo was well stocked with plenty of beach items and being able to throw everything into the beach wagon was great!
- Anonymous, N/A, CO

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

I spent 12 weeks at Loggerhead Cay #261 once again this winter and enjoyed my stay thoroughly. The weather was extremely cooperative for the most part, and the beach walking, as usual, was wonderful.

As always, the folks at Select Vacation Properties were friendly, helpful and professional, as has been my experience since I first started renting this property from them in December of 2013. - Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Enjoyed our second time rental of Loggerhead Cay #261 and plan on returning again. - David B., Marietta, GA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

PROS - easy walk to beach, convenient to stores on Sanibel, apartment is spacious, clean and plenty of seating, kitchen well appointed with all the cookware you need, the onsite grills were great. Check in and out was easy and safe.
CONS - complex itself not suited to the capacity of travelers, couldn't use the pool due to the crowd and the pool area was quite small and dated, kids were screaming everywhere, no one seemed to think they should try to social distance, while dog friendly, the middle of the complex is a huge yard that you cannot take the dog in. There is no view of the beach from the unit. I'd recommend this stay to friends with kids needing a spacious, beach adjacent pet friendly getaway. - Anonymous, Miami, FL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This is our third visit to Sanibel and Loggerhead Cay specifically and our first time in this unit. The condo was clean and well stocked with all the necessities to make the stay comfortable. Our big takeaway was that items in the condo were aging and could use some replacing. For example, the bed linens, beach chairs, some furniture, and some of the doors and appliances. Maintenance was out a couple of times to address the issues and were very professional and helpful. We loved being on the ground floor and appreciated the condo's location on the grounds. - Allison P., Gurley, AL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We loved the location of the condo. The beach and pool were perfect. The complex was beautiful! Our condo could’ve been a bit cleaner and unfortunately our king bed was broken and very uncomfortable. We had a wonderful time! - Anonymous, Madison, CT

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

I rented Unit #261 - Loggerhead Cay for 12 weeks this winter. I am very satisfied with both premises and property management personnel, so much so that I have booked again for 2018-2019.

The description of the location, layout, and amenities is accurate.

Proximity to the beach and Gulf of Mexico is very high on my priority list. The weather was fantastic this year, other than a few cooler days in January and just before my departure. I walked on the beach for hours virtually every afternoon, often clad only in my bathing suit.

Being able to manage quite nicely on Sanibel without a car is another plus from my perspective. Everything that I need to access is within what I consider to be easy walking distance. For example, it takes me half an hour to get to Jerry's Shopping Centre and 50 minutes or so to reach Sanibel Public Library. Whether walking or cycling, the paved trails are both convenient and safe. Having said that, I appreciated having access to a rental car when I had company on at least four occasions this winter, since that meant being able to purchase most of my groceries and other supplies in Fort Myers, where there is more variety and the prices are lower. Given that I am vegan and prefer to prepare my own meals, rather than eating out, grocery shopping off island is very appealing.

The unit was not **** and span when I arrived, and whomever stayed there before me failed to report some required maintenance work and missing essentials. However, the folks at Select Vacation Properties provided cheerful, prompt and excellent service (generally same day), whether I needed a lightbulb or chaise lounge replaced or some additional hangers purchased.

The grounds and facilities are well maintained and the setting is generally very quiet, except when the grounds crew members are at work on Wednesday mornings or there are excited children in the pool.

Virtually everyone whom I encountered throughout my stay w - Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We had a nice week Loggerhead Cay #261. Very short walk to the pool, about 100 yards to the beach. nicely furnished and plenty of room for 5 people. - Mark R., Everett, PA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We had a wonderful time at this condo. Easy check in & check out process. Very clean and comfortable. Close to the beach and quiet. We are definitely looking into renting again! - Maura M., Rochester, Minnesota

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Select Vacation is the best! They took great care of my family and I. We stayed at a very clean condo that was close to the pool and the beach. This was our 3rd year staying with SVP at Loggerhead Cay. We’ve already booked for next year! - Gerald M., Harrisburg, NC

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

3rd year we have stayed at Laggerhead Cay - great location,condo had everything needed,clean, and nice to have a washer and dryer for the week. Some of the furniture is a bit dated, may need an update in a bit - had bikes delivered for the week from Billy's - had the pool to ourselves most afternoons - - Judy L., Odessa, FL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

It was wonderful. Sanibel is a great place to vacation and have fun. Loggerhead Cay was a very nice place to stay. Right on the beach, nice pool and quiet. - Maureen R., CONCORD, NH

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This was our first trip to Florida for vacation. Sanibel Island was laid-back and relaxing. Our lodgings were top notch. This rating would have been a 5 across the board but the mattresses need to be replaced. - Paula B., WESTMINSTER, MD

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This is the sixth winter that I have rented Unit 261 at Loggerhead Cay through Select Vacation Properties. The company personnel are extremely friendly and helpful and maintenance requests are always handled very promptly. The unit, itself, is bright and spacious, and I like the fact that it is situated on the ground floor, which means being able to access the courtyard via the lanai door and is only minutes from both pool and beach. - Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Nice place, could use a lttle refresher. - Anonymous, Duluth, MN

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This was our second time staying at this property. We love it and will return! Great location, great facitilies, and awesome beach access. Condo is perfect- great amenties. Very happy and will return!! - Maura M., Rochester, Minnesota

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Unit was clean and adequately stocked for a weeks getaway. Good location close to everything. - Linda M., ,

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Great location great prices - Anonymous, Clear Lake, IA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We just rented unit #261 in Loggerhead Cay, and really our time. The place was clean, decor was nice, and surprisingly all the rooms were spacious. We had a total of 5 and it never felt cramped. The kitchen was well equipped. We were very surprised at how quiet it was considering the places all seem pretty booked but you never heard noise!! We would definitely stay again!! - Anonymous, Lakewood, NJ

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This condo was nicely decorated and had everything we needed. The photos were very accurate. It was close to the pool and beach which worked well for us and our 4 1/2 yr old. They had a beach chair, umbrella, beach toys and three beach towels for us to use. We liked the island location as well since it was an easy drive to the shops,restaurants,library, post office and grocery stores. We were able to get a temporary library membership and checkout kids games and puzzles as well as kids books. We enjoyed the Ding darling refuge area. We had a great dinner at Doc Ford's our last night, really good seafood. The coffee and pastries at Bennett's roasted were very good. We also had a good dinner at George and Wendy's , good shrimp tacos and ribs. Really nice wait staff!

The only problem we had was with the wireless service which I was never able to get the password etc for even though I requested by phone. The management company should have that worked out before their next clients since I let them know at the office when I dropped off the keys. I used my hotspot all week but would have preferred wireless. They were very prompt in taking care of some minor maintence issues and very pleasant to deal with overall. We really enjoyed our vacation at this condo and would definitely recommend this location. - Anonymous, Towson, MD

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

The property description was totally accurate in terms of location, layout, amenities, etc. I have never met the owners of the condo that I rent through Select Vacation Properties, but the unit is nicely furnished and decorated, and the kitchen well equipped. The property management firm employees and the maintenance person who works for the firm do an excellent job, responding immediately to any requests. The Loggerhead Cay grounds are clean and well maintained, and the complex provides a very quiet setting, since many of the units are owned and/or rented by seniors.

My preferred activities are walking on the beach for hours every afternoon, along the edge of the Gulf of Mexico, thereby keeping fit and getting a great tan, and swimming in the salt-water pool from 4:00 to 5:00 each day, weather permitting, which is an adults-only swim time. (There is another from 8:00 to 9:00 a.m.). The beach is less than 5 minutes from the unit, and was well used, but never congested. (Having said that, I leave before the March break crowds descend).

I was on Sanibel without a car . . . The paved trails along the major routes are great for walking, running and cycling, and make accessing stores, the library, etc. safe and convenient.

I have rented the same unit for twelve/thirteen weeks for the past three winters, and made a reservation for 2016-2017, so clearly I am well satisfied. - Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We had an incredible vacation at Sanibel Island. Our family of 5 thoroughly loved our condo at Loggerhead Cay. It was beautiful and the complex is very well maintained. The beaches along Sanibel and Captiva are amazing. We shelled for hours each day. We drove 17 hours to get to get to Sanibel and it was totally worth the trip. We cannot wait to return! - Jennifer F., Greensboro, NC

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We've stayed at Loggerhead Cay many times and always love it there. Location is really optimal, it's clean and really well taken care of. We love the bottom floor for bringing in beach chairs, cart, etc everyday from the beach. It pretty much feels like home to us! - Chris R., Morton, IL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

I am actually staying in Unit #261 until Saturday, March 11, 2017, but received two separate bookings - one covering the first two weeks and the other 10 weeks in 2017. This is my fourth winter staying at this unit, and I am happy to be back. The property description is accurate; the property is clean and well maintained; Select Vacation Property provides excellent customer service; and I would recommend this property to friends or relatives. - Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

I rented Unit #261 - Loggerhead Cay for 12 weeks this winter, but already reviewed my stay from December 12 to January 1. That I am very satisfied with both premises and property management personnel is reflected by the fact that I have booked again for 2017-18.

The description of the location, layout, and amenities is accurate.

Proximity to the beach and Gulf of Mexico is very high on my priority list. The weather was fantastic this year and I walked on the beach for hours virtually every afternoon, often clad only in my bathing suit. I also took advantage of the adults-only swim time in the pool in the late afternoon.

That I can manage quite nicely on Sanibel without a car is another plus from my perspective. Everything that I need to access is within what is my idea of easy walking distance. For example, it takes me a half hour to get to Gerry’s and 45 minutes to reach Sanibel Public Library. Whether walking or cycling, the paved trails are both convenient and safe.

Having said that, I appreciated having access to a rental car when I had company on five occasions this winter, since that meant being able to purchase most of my groceries and other supplies in Fort Myers, where there is more variety and prices are lower. Given that I am vegan and prefer to prepare my own meals, grocery shopping off island is particularly appealing.

The unit was not **** and span when I arrived, and whomever stayed there before me failed to report some required maintenance work. However, the folks at Select Vacation Properties provided cheerful, prompt and excellent service (generally same day), whether I needed a damaged door repaired or new dish cloths & towels, or made a rate inquiry for next year.

The grounds and facilities are well maintained and the setting is generally very quiet, except when the grounds crew members are working or there are excited children in the pool.

Virtually everyone I encountered throug - Gini S., Woodstock, Ont

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Our condo was a perfect fit for our family of 5...very comfortable and clean. We would rent it again, and will let friends and family know about Loggerhead Cay! - Anonymous, Healy, AK

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Our condo was great and only a short walk to the pool or beach. We loved there were a lot of families with kids there for our daughter to play with. We will definitely return! - Megan H., Paris, Kentucky

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

This property was amazing and had every that you need to have a great vacation on Sanibel, my smallest complaint would be that the fully stocked kitchen did not have one non stick pan to make eggs in the morning. If we get lucky enough to come back, I will gift one to these lucky condo owners. the place is very well appointed and very clean. - Anonymous, Miami, FL

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

everything was great just wish water was like it should be not your fault see u guys next year Larry - Larry W., oxford, oh

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Everything from start to finish of our vacation was awesome. The condo was clean and very nice. It was a very short walk to the pool and the beach. Our unit was close to local attractions in Sanibel. We liked it so much that we booked it again before we left! - Gerald M., Harrisburg, NC

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

We stayed in the condo for 12 nights leading up to Thanksgiving 2016 and it was superb.

Location is perfect, right on the beach. Facilities at the condos are great with a decent pool, tennis and shuffleboard. Very quiet, particularly when you consider it was almost full by Thanksgiving but no noise or disturbance.

The condo itself was well fitted out with brand new appliances, fully stocked kitchen, great cable TV and internet, washer / dryer etc. Couldn't ask for more.

We hired bikes for the full time from Finnimores and hardly used the car whilst on the island.

Top tip, walk up Beach Road opposite to get to Bennett's on Periwinkle for morning coffee and donuts. The walk gives you a decent excuse to indulge :-) - Anonymous, Manchester, XX

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

The condo was very nice. The accommodations were everything we thought they would be. It was just a short walk to the beach, short bike ride to restaurants & shopping & a very friendly vibe. We can't wait to return!!! - Anonymous, LaGrange, ME

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes

Perfect! One minor thing.... the beach chairs could be upgraded. - Carol M., Newburyport, MA

Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others Yes